Recommendations needed

TalkManga and Anime Addicts

Join LibraryThing to post.

Recommendations needed

1Sorceress_rin
Jun 5, 2010, 9:21 am

I recently got a request from someone to find manga for a 12 year old girl to relate to and I am having a hard time thinking of anything good that would be within that age range.
If anyone could suggest a title that would be greatly appreciated ^_^

2keristars
Jun 5, 2010, 10:44 am

Any idea what kinds of things the girl likes?

The first one that comes to mind for me is Gakuen Alice, because it seems to be aimed at middle school girls, and it is pretty popular. At least at the beginning, it has comedy and romance and drama, plus the fantasy element.

3Sorceress_rin
Jun 5, 2010, 7:53 pm

Great idea, I've actually never met the girl. My local comic book store owner asked me to create a list because he knows nothing of manga and he was asked by her therapist or something .

4keristars
Jun 5, 2010, 10:26 pm

Not having met her makes it difficult. It's so hard to recommend books for "12 year olds" and "girls" because maturity level, reading level, and interests vary *so* much. And especially with that age group, you get some who are ready to read things like Twilight, and otehrs for whom the themes are a bit too heavy. So Gakuen Alice seems pretty safe, but then maybe the girl prefers the kinds of stories that you get with Naruto or Bleach, or maybe she's really into supernatural stuff. :/

Another recommendation is Happy Cafe since it ran in the same magazine as Gakuen Alice and is pretty all-ages, that I recall. It's more of a slice-of-life relationship thing than the plotty drama that you get in Gakuen Alice, and there's a lot more comedy. But there isn't the insane shoujo angst of other popular series like Fruits Basket, which maybe she's not quite ready for (and there's no way to tell without knowing her).

Tsubasa: Reservoir Chronicle might be another good choice, and for another CLAMP, there's Cardcaptor Sakura...

I'm trying my best to think of titles that I see all the time at Barnes & Noble that might appeal to younger teens. I can see the colors of the spines on the shelves, but most of the titles are escaping me. -.- I'm especially trying to think of things from the shounen side (thus T:RC), but I personally hate Naruto and Bleach and One Piece, so I don't want to recommend them. :P

5lilasia
Jun 7, 2010, 4:17 pm

i think there are quite a few manga out there where the heroine is at about the same age or younger... try kodocha.. there is some tragedy involved, but the story is enjoyable, and pretty much a classic.

6EliSimons
Jun 8, 2010, 8:24 pm

shugo chara is good for 12 year old girls, but it depends on what they prefer.

7novelandmangacrazy
Jun 11, 2010, 4:39 pm

what about Angelic layer?

I'm not sure about these , but you could check them out.

D.N.Angel
Forbidden Dance
Dramacon

8Taigamimi
Oct 17, 2010, 4:52 pm

Ultra Maniac. It's a romantic fantasy and is all ages. The story is simple and sweet, yet very entertaining at the same time. If she's looking for something on the edgier side try St. Dragon Girl

9ruby_x1
Oct 15, 4:23 pm

damn.........

10Sxkurablossom
Oct 16, 12:00 pm

?

111hope
Oct 16, 12:06 pm

?

12Sxkurablossom
Oct 16, 12:10 pm

?

13katzuo_kxtty
Oct 16, 6:19 pm

?

14Sxkurablossom
Oct 17, 8:37 am

?

15Someone757
Oct 17, 8:38 am

?

16Sxkurablossom
Oct 17, 8:40 am

?

17katzuo_kxtty
Oct 17, 8:44 am

?

18Bazlisprout
Oct 17, 8:45 am

?

19Someone757
Oct 17, 8:50 am

?

20Abinadiyinyang
Oct 17, 11:00 am

WHAT????????!!!!!!!!!!!!

21Sxkurablossom
Oct 17, 11:11 am

?

22Abinadiyinyang
Oct 17, 11:14 am

bruh

23Sxkurablossom
Oct 17, 11:16 am

?

241hope
Oct 17, 11:47 am

?

25Sxkurablossom
Oct 17, 12:55 pm

?

26Someone757
Oct 17, 1:31 pm

?ㅤㅤㅤ

27katzuo_kxtty
Edited: Oct 17, 1:35 pm

?

281hope
Oct 17, 3:24 pm

?‎

29Someone757
Yesterday, 9:15 am

?

30Bazlisprout
Yesterday, 9:21 am

I SHALL BREAK THE CHAIN

31Someone757
Yesterday, 9:25 am

DAMMIT

32Bazlisprout
Yesterday, 9:27 am

HAHAHAHHHAHAHAH

33Someone757
Yesterday, 9:29 am

hold up i got a fire alarm

34Someone757
Yesterday, 9:29 am

brb

35Bazlisprout
Yesterday, 9:45 am

mkay

36Someone757
Yesterday, 9:49 am

I'm back- someone pulled the damn alarm again

37Bazlisprout
Yesterday, 9:50 am

damn that sucks

38Someone757
Yesterday, 9:50 am

not really... my class is boring anyways

39Bazlisprout
Yesterday, 9:51 am

hm you wanna rp or smth?

40Someone757
Yesterday, 9:51 am

idk tbh, its been a while since i did any rp

41Bazlisprout
Yesterday, 9:52 am

hm why dont you join my demo slayer rp on my group? that could be fun

42Someone757
Yesterday, 9:53 am

eh sure

43Someone757
Yesterday, 9:53 am

I have yet to watch it tho so itll be a little while till i rp

44Bazlisprout
Yesterday, 9:53 am

i mean what do you have to lose?

45Bazlisprout
Yesterday, 9:54 am

461hope
Yesterday, 1:08 pm

>30 Bazlisprout: screw you kys

47Bazlisprout
Yesterday, 1:09 pm

Join to post